The Eleventh Circuit has ruled that the plaintiff’s act of amending its complaint may allow a defendant to resurrect its previously-waived right to arbitrate. “[I]n limited circumstances, fairness dictates that a waiver of arbitration be nullified by the filing of an amended complaint.” Krinsk v. Suntrust Banks, Inc., __ F.3d ___, 2011 WL 3902998,
arbitration
Yes, Virginia, There is Injunctive Relief in Court Despite An Arbitration Clause
A recent decision from the Western District of Oklahoma reminds all litigators that you may be able to get preliminary injunctive relief from the courts, despite having a valid arbitration agreement. Although this seems to fly in the face of the courts’ general arbitration refrain (stolen from M.C. Hammer: “[We] Can’t Touch This”), courts rationalize…
Another State Law Bites the Concepcion Dust
In April, the Supreme Court struck down a common law rule in California that declared most consumer arbitration agreements void if they prohibit classwide arbitration of claims, holding that it was preempted by the Federal Arbitration Act. AT&T Mobility, LLC v. Concepcion, 131S. Ct. 1740 ( 2011). In the last few weeks, two federal circuit…
Has The Parade of Predicted Horribles From Rent-A-Center Come To Pass?
Just over a year has passed since the U.S. Supreme Court applied the severability doctrine in Rent-A-Center, West Inc. v. Jackson, 130 S. Ct. 2772 (2010), in such a way that Justice Stevens and three others dissented, raising the specter of “infinite layers of severability” and a parade of arbitrability horribles. A review of…
Proving A Waiver of Arbitration Rights Is Now Easier In Construction Cases (8th Cir.)
A party with an arbitration agreement can waive its right to arbitrate by acting inconsistently with that right, usually by “invoking the litigation machinery” before demanding arbitration. However, the federal circuits are split over whether a party asserting a waiver of arbitration must also show it was prejudiced by the other party’s use of that…
The Arbitrator Finds The Contract Invalid. Now What?
What is an arbitrator to do after concluding that the parties’ entire agreement — the same agreement that authorized the arbitration proceeding — is invalid? That is the question that the California Court of Appeal addressed this week. The California court ruled that the arbitrator was authorized to reach a decision on the merits of…